Etsy Copyright Infringement: The Essential Guide

Etsy, an e-commerce platform with millions of unique products, allows small businesses and independent creators to showcase their work. It also opens the door to potential intellectual property issues.

With Etsy’s total active sellers surpassing 9 million in 2023, the scale of potential copyright issues has grown, as sellers need to remain aware of copyright compliance to avoid legal risks.

If you’re a seller on Etsy, you need to be aware of the risks associated with copyright infringement policy.

Infringing on someone else’s intellectual property can result in serious consequences, including legal action, account suspension, and loss of revenue.

In this guide, we will explore what copyright infringement means on Etsy, how to avoid it, and the steps you can take to safeguard your brand while respecting the intellectual property of others.

Stay protected and compliant!

What is Copyright Infringement?

Copyright infringement occurs when someone uses another person’s creative work without permission.

Copyright laws protect original works like books, music, films, artwork, and software. When these works are used without proper authorisation, it violates the creator’s exclusive rights, which include the right to reproduce, distribute, and display the work.

For example, if a person downloads and shares a movie or song without paying for it or obtaining the necessary license, that’s a form of copyright infringement.

Even using someone else’s images or text in a blog or social media post without proper credit or permission can fall under infringement.

Actions for copyright infringement includes fines, penalties, or lawsuits. In some cases, if the violation is severe, it could lead to criminal charges.

However, there are exceptions, such as “fair use,” which allows limited use of copyrighted material for purposes like education, news reporting, or criticism, without needing permission.

To avoid copyright violations, it’s important to seek permission or use content that’s licensed for reuse, such as public domain works or material under a Creative Commons copyright.

Always give proper credit to the original creators and respect their intellectual property rights.

Additionally, businesses should implement best practices for intellectual property management to avoid legal issues and support ethical content usage.

Etsy Copyright Infringement

Etsy is a popular online marketplace that allows creators to sell their original creations.

However, with so many sellers and products available, it can be difficult for copyright holders to identify and address every instance of copyright infringement on the platform.

According to Etsy’s user agreement, each active seller is responsible for the items they post and the branding used in their shop, and the site is not liable for any infringement that occurs.

If copyright infringement is discovered, the first step is often to send a cease and desist letter. Litigation is also an option if necessary.

Copyright law protects a wide range of creative works that can be sold on Etsy, including photographs, paintings, sculptures, books, novels, poetry, and crafts.

Visual art is also a concern on Etsy, with examples of potential copyright infringement including T-shirts featuring photographs, reproductions of digital art designs, photographs of sculptures or figures, postcards with original designs, and framed prints of poetry.

Even copying and pasting listing information from other sellers can be a violations of copyright.

If you discover that your copyrighted material has been used without permission on Etsy, you can file a report of infringement under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) to have the offending page or listing removed.

Submitting a DMCA response is an option to have your product listing or store reinstated.

However, it is important to seek timely advice before taking any action.

How does Copyright Infringement Happen on Etsy?

Copyright violations on Etsy can occur when an active seller offers items for sale that contain images, designs, or other creative works that are protected by copyright without obtaining proper permission from the original owner.

This can happen in a few different ways:

• Selling items with copyrighted images: A seller may create products that feature copyrighted images, such as characters from movies, TV shows, or video games, without obtaining a license or permission from the copyright holder.
• Using copyrighted designs: A seller may use a copyrighted design, such as a pattern or print, without obtaining permission from the copyright owner.
• Copying original product descriptions or titles: A seller may copy original product descriptions or titles from other sellers without obtaining permission, which could potentially infringe on the original seller’s copyright.
• Reproducing copyrighted works: A seller may reproduce a copyrighted work, such as a piece of licensed artwork, without obtaining permission from the actual owner.

If a copyright owner discovers that their creative material has been used without permission on Etsy, they can file a complaint about copyright infringement with Etsy’s Intellectual Property team.

Etsy will then review the seller reporting and may remove the infringing items from the platform, suspend the active seller’s account, or take other actions as necessary to resolve the intellectual property issue.

Additionally, the content creators may choose to pursue legal action against the seller for infringing on their copyright property rights.

Cease and Desist Letter

When someone’s exclusive rights are infringed upon, one of the most effective ways to address the issue is by sending a copyright cease and desist letter.

This legal document provides notice to the infringing party that their actions are unauthorised and must stop.

Cease and desist letters are a powerful tool in resolving copyright issues, as they often prevent the issue from escalating to the court system.

In fact, some copyright disputes are resolved through the use of cease and desist letters.

By sending a cease and desist letter, you can also establish evidence of willful copyright infringement, which can significantly increase the amount of financial compensation awarded in court.

If someone is found to have intentionally infringed on copyright, they may face a higher maximum penalty in court.

Instead of being limited to a range of $750 to $30,000 (statutory damage) per infringement, the maximum penalty may be increased to $150,000.

However, it’s important to note that the copyright must be registered in order to be eligible for such awards.

Copyright Litigation On Etsy

Copyright infringement lawsuit on Etsy can be necessary if someone submits a DMCA counter-notice against you. In such cases, you may need to file a copyright lawsuit to defend your copyright in court.

However, it’s essential to note that you’ll need to federally register your copyright to enjoy full intellectual property protections.

If you choose to go to court, you must respond immediately when you receive a counter-notice.

Failing to do so will allow the infringer to have their listing reinstated, and they may assume they can infringe on your works in the future with no consequences.

Before choosing to go to court, you should consider several factors.

• Did the infringement happen intentionally?
• Have they stopped infringing completely?
• Did you suffer significant financial losses?
• Considering their potential profits and legal expenses, is it worth going to court?
• Have you sent a cease and desist letter?

Assessing these factors can aid in determining if litigation is the optimal choice. If the violation persists or the seller challenges your claim of copyright, pursuing legal action may be necessary.

How Etsy Handles Copyright Infringement Reports from Sellers?

If you’re an Etsy seller, you might be wondering how the e-commerce platform handles copyright infringement notices.

Here’s the lowdown: If someone believes that you’re infringing on their intellectual property, they can report it to Etsy.

Once Etsy receives the report and confirms that it’s valid, they’re required to remove the content in question. It’s important to note that Etsy doesn’t just randomly take down listings without reason.

If your listing on Etsy has been reported for IP violations of copyright, you’ll receive an automated notice from the platform informing you that the listing has been deactivated.

It’s also worth noting that Etsy doesn’t accept infringement reports from just anyone. The report must come from the intellectual property owner themselves.

So, you don’t need to worry about your competitors trying to take down your shop.

Etsy takes these reports seriously and ensures that they’re valid before taking any action. So, if you receive an infringement notice, it’s important to take it seriously and address the issue to avoid any further consequences.

You can also file a counter-notice if you believe the claim is incorrect. Etsy may reinstate your listing if it’s found that no infringement occurred.

Communication with Etsy and knowing the claims is essential to resolving the issue effectively.

Is Copyright Infringement a Concern for Etsy Sellers?

As a seller on Etsy, it’s important to have a good knowledge of copyright laws and avoid any violations.

Etsy has strict policies in place to protect intellectual property rights, and failure to comply with these policies can result in severe consequences, including the closure of your shop or legal action against you by the copyright holder.

It’s worth noting that Etsy does not actively check every listing for copyright infringement, so it’s your responsibility as a business owner to ensure that you are not infringing on anyone’s intellectual property.

In many cases, Etsy sellers are caught for violations of copyright due to reports made by other Etsy shop owners or the copyright owners themselves.

Large corporations, such as Disney, have pursued legal action against small businesses for utilising their intellectual property without authorisation.

This is why it’s essential for Etsy sellers to only use content that they have the legal right to use or obtain permission or a license for any copyrighted content they wish to use.

Additionally, sellers should be cautious when creating or sourcing designs that could resemble well-known brands, characters, or logos, as even unintentional infringement can lead to serious consequences.

Taking proactive steps to protect your shop can save you from costly legal disputes and maintain your reputation on the platform.

How to Avoid Copyright Infringement on Etsy?

As an Etsy seller, it’s essential to take steps to avoid copyright infringement. Here are some tips to keep in mind:

Create Original Content

The best way to avoid copyright infringement is to create your own original content. This includes everything from product designs to product photography.

By creating your own content, you can be sure that you’re not violating anyone else’s intellectual property rights.

Original content not only protects you legally but also helps you build a unique brand identity that sets you apart from competitors.

Custom graphic designs, unique product descriptions, and self-shot product images showcase your creativity and professionalism, making your shop more appealing to potential buyers.

If you do need to use external content, make sure you obtain proper licenses or permissions and credit the original creator where necessary.

Using royalty-free resources or purchasing design licenses are also viable options if creating everything from scratch isn’t feasible.

However, the safest and most rewarding path is always to focus on originality and authenticity, ensuring that your shop remains compliant with copyright laws while fostering long-term brand success.

Obtain Permission

If you want to use someone else’s creative work, you need to obtain permission first. This might mean contacting the original creator and asking for their permission to use their work.

If they agree, be sure to get the agreement in writing to avoid any potential misunderstandings later.

Having a written agreement ensures that you have legal documentation outlining the terms of use, such as how the content can be used, where it can be displayed, and any associated costs or credits.

This written consent can be a formal contract or even an email agreement, but it’s crucial to have it documented.

Sometimes, creators will offer licenses for their work, which can specify the type of usage allowed, such as for personal or commercial purposes.

Be sure to fully know the scope of the permission or license you’re obtaining, as misusing the work beyond the agreed terms could still result in copyright infringement.

Respecting intellectual property rights not only keeps your business compliant but also builds a reputation for professionalism and ethical practices.

Use Public Domain Content

Public domain content is content that is not protected by copyright laws.

This includes things like old books and films, as well as images and other creative works that have been released into the public domain.

You can use public domain content without fear of copyright infringement.

Using public domain content can be a great way to add value to your products, marketing, or graphic designs while staying compliant with intellectual property laws.

However, it’s important to verify that the content is indeed in the public domain, as copyright durations vary by country and type of work.

For example, works published before 1924 in the U.S. are generally considered public domain. There are also resources like Project Gutenberg and Wikimedia Commons, which offer access to public domain texts and images.

By leveraging public domain materials, you can enhance your business offerings while avoiding the legal risks associated with copyrighted material.

Use Royalty-Free Content

Royalty-free content is material that you can use without having to pay recurring fees for each use, making it a cost-effective option for businesses and creators. This type of content typically includes stock images, music, videos, and even graphic designs.

When you purchase or download royalty-free content, you usually pay a one-time fee or no fee at all, depending on the platform, and then you’re granted the rights to use it under specific conditions.

However, it’s essential to carefully read the terms of use or license agreement for any royalty-free content. Some licenses may have restrictions, such as limits on commercial use, distribution, or modification.

For example, some stock photos may be used for marketing materials but not for resale on products. Comprehending these terms ensures that you stay within the legal boundaries and avoid potential copyright issues.

By using no copyright concent responsibly, you can enhance your creative projects while staying compliant with intellectual property laws.

How to Report Copyright Infringement on Etsy?

When it comes to intellectual property infringement, Etsy takes swift action to remove or disable access to any material that allegedly infringes on someone’s intellectual property rights.

If you submit a report for copyright infringement that is compliant with Etsy’s policies, the company will do everything in its power to respond promptly and address the issue.

Etsy’s process for handling infringement reports is straightforward. They will attempt to contact the member whose content has been flagged and inform them of the situation.

They will also provide information about the report and removal, as well as instructions on how to submit a counter notice if necessary.

To submit an infringement report, Etsy provides two different portals. For usernames, shop names, and videos, you can use the Etsy Reporting Form.

To report infringement against Etsy shop listings, the Etsy Reporting Portal is the best option.

This portal is also used to report infringement to Etsy’s Designated Agent under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and other intellectual property rights.

Prior to initiating the processing of reports of infringement, Etsy may request more information.

This may include a letter of consent from the content creators, proof of the reporting party’s identity, or any other relevant evidence pertaining to copyright claims.

However, they may reject reports that are deemed to be false, fraudulent, incomplete, or submitted in bad faith. Etsy has the authority to respond to any violations of this policy.

It’s clear that Etsy takes intellectual property infringement seriously and is committed to maintaining a fair and safe online marketplace.

By following their reporting procedures, individuals can help Etsy uphold its policies and protect intellectual property rights.

What are the Potential Consequences of Receiving a Copyright Infringement Notice on Etsy?

If you receive a copyright infringement notice from Etsy, it means that the platform has detected that you have used copyrighted material without permission and has removed the infringing content.

This can result in the removal or disablement of your listing or even your entire shop. Etsy takes intellectual property rights very seriously and will act swiftly upon receiving a report of the alleged infringement.

It’s important to note that Etsy will not reach out to you to ask for clarification or information before removing the infringing material.

Instead, they will remove or disable access to the content and then send you a copyright infringement takedown notice to inform you that the material has been removed.

However, if you believe that you are not infringing on any intellectual property rights, you have the option to submit a counter notice to Etsy in accordance with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).

This means that you can dispute the claim and provide evidence to support your argument. If Etsy finds that your counter-notice is valid, they may reinstate the removed content.

Receiving multiple copyright infringement notices can lead to more severe consequences, such as permanent suspension of your Etsy account.

Additionally, the copyright holder may pursue legal action against you, resulting in costly litigation or fines.

Therefore, addressing any copyright-related issues promptly and responsibly is critical to protecting your business.

Are Maximum Number of Copyright Strikes Allowed on Etsy?

Etsy has the authority to close a shop that violates copyright laws, even if it’s the first offense, and there’s no set policy regarding the number of strikes a shop can get before they take action. Etsy’s decision is at its sole discretion and can be made at any time without prior warning.

For example, a seller on Etsy might create and sell jewelry that uses an image of a popular cartoon character without proper licensing or permission from the copyright owner.

If the copyright owner reports the seller to Etsy for infringement, the platform may remove the specific product listings, or worse, shut down the entire shop on the first violation.

However, in some cases, Etsy may only remove specific listings or commercial products rather than shutting down the entire shop listings.

For example, a seller might use an image or popular design that is similar to another company’s original design elements, and the company reports the seller to Etsy for infringement.

In this case, Etsy may remove the infringing product listings but allow the Etsy seller to keep their shop open.

To avoid copyright strikes and potential shop closures, it’s essential for Etsy sellers to learn and adhere to intellectual property laws.

Additionally, receiving multiple copyright infringement notices may increase the likelihood of Etsy permanently suspending the seller’s account, so staying compliant with intellectual property guidelines is essential for long-term success on the platform.

What to Do If You’ve Been Accused of Copyright Infringement on Etsy?

As an Etsy seller, it’s crucial to be mindful of copyright infringement and to take any notices received seriously.

If you receive a copyright infringement notice on Etsy, it’s important to assess whether or not you have indeed violated any intellectual property laws.

Review the Accusation

Take the time to review the accusation carefully. Look at the specific claims being made and try to know why the accuser believes that you’ve infringed on their copyright.

Respond Promptly

If you believe it is groundless allegations, respond promptly and professionally. In this case, you have the option to file a counter notice to dispute the claim.

Remove the Infringing Content

If you know that you have violated the law (e.g. by selling copyrighted material), it’s crucial to take prompt action. One effective way to do this is by conducting an audit of your store and removing any infringing material.

This will help you to comply with IP laws and avoid the risk of legal action being taken against you. This will show the accuser that you take the accusation seriously and are willing to take steps to correct the situation.

Seek Legal Advice

If you’re unsure of your legal rights and obligations, seek legal advice from an intellectual property lawyer. They can help you know the laws that apply to your situation and provide guidance on pre-empting future allegations.

Do Etsy Images have Copyright Protection?

Imagine you’re a painter and you’ve just created a beautiful masterpiece. The moment you put down your brush, your creation becomes protected by something called copyright.

This means that nobody else can use or reproduce your work without your permission.

Now, let’s say you decide to sell your painting on Etsy. You take a picture of it and upload it to your shop. That picture is also automatically protected by copyright, just like the original painting.

Adding a copyright symbol (©) to your work is like putting up a sign that says “This is creator exclusive, don’t touch it!” However, even if you don’t include the symbol, your work is still protected.

Think of copyright registration like a secret code that only you know.

When you register your copyright, it’s like adding an extra layer of protection and making it easier for you to prove that the work is yours.

But remember, you can’t register a copyright if the work already belongs to someone else. So, always make sure that the work you’re creating is truly original.

Additionally, copyright protection for images extends to digital formats.

This means that your Etsy product photos, graphics, and artwork are safeguarded against unauthorised use, ensuring your intellectual property remains secure.

Is Disney Artwork Selled on Etsy?

Selling Disney art on Etsy is not allowed because Disney owns the rights to their images, logos, and names, which means they have legal control over how its patent is used.

This includes popular characters like Mickey Mouse, Cinderella, and other beloved Disney characters. Even if you are only using these characters in your artwork or product, it is still considered illegal to sell on Etsy.

Disney takes their intellectual property very seriously and has been known to take legal action against small businesses and creators who infringe on its copyrights and trademarks.

Such actions can lead to significant legal consequences, including fines to jail time, which can be financially damaging and harm your business reputation.

It is important to note that the consequences of selling Disney-inspired artwork can be harmful to your business, especially if you have not set up your business properly or protected your personal assets.

Therefore, it is best to avoid selling any original artwork or products that incorporate Disney’s copyrighted or trademarked material.

Instead, focus on creating original content or using licensed, royalty-free images to ensure your Etsy shop remains compliant with copyright laws and avoids legal risks.

What’s Next?

Copyright infringement is a complex matter that should not be taken lightly by any intellectual property owner.

With millions of sellers and items on Etsy, it can be a challenge to protect your creations and your brand. However, by taking the necessary steps to prevent infringement and promptly responding to any accusations, you can safeguard your business and its reputation.

By adhering to copyright laws, creating original content, seeking permission when needed, and staying up-to-date on intellectual property policy, you can establish a thriving and sustainable business on Etsy.

Enjoy the peace of mind that comes with Bytescare digital protection.

Our advanced digital piracy monitoring covers everything from detection to ongoing vigilance, ensuring your content remains secure and free from unauthorised use.

This allows you to focus on what truly matters—your creativity and innovation. Elevate your digital security and protect your legacy.

Transform your approach to digital safety today. Book a demo to see how we can help.

FAQs