Punishment For Plagiarism In India: Know the Laws

Plagiarism is the act of using someone else’s work or ideas without proper acknowledgment. It is a serious issue in academic, creative, and professional fields. It undermines the integrity of intellectual property and devalues the hard work of original creators.

In India, the legal and educational systems have specific measures in place to address plagiarism.

This article gives you useful insight into the punishment for plagiarism in India. It also explores the various forms of plagiarism, the legal framework governing it, the consequences for individuals and institutions, and the broader implications for Indian society.

What Does Plagiarism Include?

Plagiarism involves using someone else’s work or ideas without giving proper credit. It can take many forms, from copying text to using someone’s ideas as your own.

Here are some examples of what constitutes plagiarism:

• Images: Using photographs taken by someone else without permission or credit.
• Videos: Sharing or using videos recorded by others without acknowledgment.
• Covers: Performing or recording a cover of someone else’s work without giving credit.
• Slogans: Using catchphrases or slogans created by others as your own.
• Articles: Copying written articles without citing the original author.
• Ideas: Presenting someone else’s ideas or concepts as your own.

It is essential to obtain consent or give proper acknowledgment when borrowing any work from someone else.

What Plagiarism Does Not Include?

Plagiarism does not include the following elements:

Table of Content: The structured listing of chapters or sections in a document.

Bibliography: A list of sources and references used in the research or document.

References: Citations of other works or studies that are properly acknowledged.

Generic Terms: Commonly used words and phrases that are not unique or original to a particular work.

Standard Symbols: Universally accepted symbols and notations used in various fields such as mathematics, science, and engineering.

Standard Equations: Commonly recognised and widely used mathematical or scientific equations.

These elements are generally considered non-original content and are not subject to intellectual theft concerns when used appropriately.

Types of Plagiarism

• Clone – plagiarism: When an author steals another author’s words verbatim and passes it off as their own, it’s known as ghostwriting.
• Remix/Potluck Paper Plagiarism: The author takes information from different sources, puts it all together in one paper, and then claims it to be his own work.
• Ctrl+C – plagiarism: This is also known as photocopy, in which a sizable section of the text is copied verbatim from the original source.
• Hybrid copying refers to the copying and arrangement of perfectly documented source documents into a new document without proper citation.
• Identify, replace, and avoid copying by altering the most often occurring terms and phrases in the copied material while leaving the main text largely unchanged.
• Recycle – copying or borrowing without giving due credit from an earlier work—a practice known as self-plagiarism.
• Mashup: Copying occurs when a material is combined without adequate reference from many sources.
• 404 Error: Plagiarism: The author copies text from multiple sources to generate a single document that is properly cited. On the other hand, it is referred to be 404 kinds plagiarism if this citation is false or points to an invalid resource.

Consequences of Plagiarism

The fields of education, science, and the arts are among the most vulnerable to the serious challenges posed by plagiarism to society. Its negative consequences can jeopardise the integrity and advancement of numerous fields.

Here are a few of the effects it may have:

Deteriorating of the Educational System

When it becomes common, it undermines the entire purpose of education – learning and critical thinking. If students can simply copy someone else’s work, it discourages them from developing their own research and writing skills. This can lead to a decline in the overall quality of education.

New Research Work Cannot Be Established

It stifles innovation. If researchers can’t rely on the originality of others’ work, it becomes difficult to build upon existing knowledge and make new discoveries. Progress in all fields would slow down significantly.

No New Creative Works

Innovation and uniqueness are vital to the creative industries. In artistic, musical, cinematic, and literary domains, plagiarism can have dire repercussions:

• Reduction in Creative Output: When creators resort to copying, the diversity and richness of new creative works diminish. Audiences are deprived of fresh perspectives and innovative content.
• Economic Impact: The creative industry contributes significantly to the economy. Plagiarism can lead to financial losses for original creators and undermine the industry’s overall growth and sustainability.
• Legal Repercussions: Authors who are found guilty of plagiarism may be subject to fines and lawsuits, which may make it more difficult for them to generate original works.

Development in All the Sectors Will Be at a Loss

Plagiarism does not only affect education and creative industries but also has broader implications for societal development:

• Technological Stagnation: In fields such as technology and engineering, plagiarism can result in the duplication of existing solutions rather than the development of innovative technologies. This hampers technological advancement and competitive edge.
• Economic Consequences: Industries relying on research and development (R&D) suffer when original ideas are stolen and commercialised by others. This can lead to loss of revenue, reduced investments in R&D, and overall economic decline.
• Public Trust: Public trust in various sectors, including healthcare, environmental science, and social sciences, is eroded when instances of plagiarism are exposed. This can affect policy-making and the implementation of critical initiatives.

Loss of Individualisation

When someone plagiarises, they’re essentially stealing someone else’s voice and ideas. This undermines the importance of developing your own unique perspective and contribution to any field. It discourages critical thinking and independent learning.

Plagiarism is a serious issue with far-reaching consequences. It weakens education, stifles innovation, and hinders progress in all areas of society.

India’s New Four-Tiered System for Punishing Plagiarism in Academic Research

A novel four-tiered system that assigns penalties based on the degree of plagiarism has been implemented in India to deal with academic plagiarism.

The University Grants Commission (UGC) developed the structure, which details the subsequent tiers:

• First Tier: Plagiarism up to 10% is considered acceptable and does not invite disciplinary action.
• Second Tier: Plagiarism between 10% and 40% requires students to revise and resubmit their work within six months, while faculty members must withdraw their papers.
• Third Tier: Plagiarism between 40% and 60% results in a one-year prohibition for students from submitting revised work. Faculty members lose their annual pay rise and face a two-year ban on supervising academic duties.
• Fourth Tier: Plagiarism over 60% leads to students being expelled from their programs. Faculty members face a two-year suspension of their pay rise and a three-year ban on academic supervision. Repeat offenders may face termination.

These regulations aim to promote academic integrity and improve the quality of research in India. However, there are concerns about potential misuse of power by educational institutions and the challenge of implementing these rules effectively.

Source: https://www.science.org/content/article/india-creates-unique-tiered-system-punish-plagiarism

Laws Concerned with Plagiarism

No Indian statute recognises the right to be free from plagiarism; nonetheless, section 57 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957 grants authors the right, among other things, to be identified as the author of their works.

Authors are granted the “special right” to be credited for their work under section 57 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957. It is perpetual in nature and a moral right. Similar to the right not to plagiarise, the Act respects the right to attribution.

Section 63 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957 regards infringement as a criminal offence, with the same penalties for both copyright infringement and section 57 violations.

Under section 63 of the Act, those found guilty of infringement face sentences of six months to three years in jail. They have also made monetary amends for their infringement.

The same act’s Section 63(A) specifies a harsher punishment for second and subsequent convictions.

Punishment for Plagiarism in India

Although plagiarism is immoral and viewed as fraud, unless it breaches copyright rules, it is not considered a crime. Nonetheless, copyright violations as well as failing to give due acknowledgment to the authors are regarded as civil offences, meaning that the specific infringer may face criminal prosecution.

Cases of plagiarism in colleges or universities are regarded as academic and legal transgressions. These intellectual theft cases are difficult to prove since the accused may claim the work was done accidentally. If proven guilty, the offender may suffer the following consequences:

• Sent to prison;
• Accused of a significant fine;
• Be suspended or expelled from an educational institution.

The legitimacy of such cases is contingent upon the intents and circumstances of the involved parties as well as the possible circumstances.

Criminal Offense and Civil Wrongs

Instead of being a criminal in and of itself, plagiarism is actually viewed as an unethical behaviour by an individual.

Both copyright infringement and the denial of an author’s right to credit are civil offences, and the offender may also face criminal prosecution.

The following remedies are available in a civil suit: damages, accounts of profit, injunctions to stop further infringement, and copies of the work that was utilised to generate the infringed material.

It’s also possible to take certain administrative measures.

Broader Implications of Plagiarism

Impact on Innovation

Because plagiarism discourages creative ideas and originality, it stifles innovation. The act of replicating preexisting works by individuals or institutions diminishes the motivation to generate novel concepts and undercuts the endeavours of the original producers.

Moral Aspects to Take into Account

Both legal and ethical issues are brought up by plagiarism. It involves breach of trust and intellectual dishonesty, which can have detrimental effects on relationships both personally and professionally.

Technology’s Role

Technology serves two purposes with regard to text appropriation. Sharing and copying of information has become easier, but it has also led to the development of systems that detect and prevent intellectual theft. The difficulty is in properly promoting academic integrity using technology.

Measures to Prevent Plagiarism

Here are some measures to prevent copying:

Promoting Academic Integrity: By fostering a culture of honesty and ethical research practices, schools can discourage students from resorting to copying or literary theft.

Developing Research Skills: Equipping students with strong research and paraphrasing techniques helps them avoid unoriginal work and idea appropriation.

Utilising Citation Tools: Teaching proper citation methods ensures students can accurately credit sources and avoid copyright infringement.

Anti-plagiarism software: It can help students find passages that require accurate citation by scanning for instances of unattributed copying.

Originality Reports: The reports produced by plagiarism detection software can help students with appropriate referencing and identify areas that need attention.

Open Communication: Encouraging open dialogue about academic integrity and the consequences of unattributed work helps students understand the importance of originality.

By implementing these measures, educational institutions can create an environment that discourages unscrupulous borrowing and promotes genuine learning.

What’s Next?

The effective resolution of plagiarism requires a comprehensive strategy due to its complexity. India has a solid basis to prevent copying thanks to the interaction of legislative frameworks, educational programmes, and technology resources. 

Consider setting up a demo to employ a Bytescare plagiarism detector and ensure the authenticity of your work so as to aid in these efforts more effectively.

FAQs