What Should Teachers Do When Students Plagiarize?

Using someone else’s work without giving due credit is known as plagiarism, and it is becoming a bigger problem in educational institutions. It compromises academic integrity and diminishes the effort that sincere students put in. But what should teachers do when students plagiarize?

A strategic approach including detection, prevention, and appropriate response methods is needed to address plagiarism. This manual will examine practical approaches to dealing with plagiarism, assisting educators in cultivating an environment of integrity and regard for intellectual property.

What is Plagiarism?

To plagiarise is to take the words, ideas, or structure of another writer and pass them off as one’s own work without giving proper credit. This can involve taking someone else’s words, pictures, or numbers and passing them off as your own. Not only is plagiarism unethical, but it is also illegal in many places.

Although on a lesser scale, ancient intellectuals were confronted with comparable challenges. However, the problem has been made worse by the digital era, which makes it more difficult to identify and easier to copy.

Various forms of plagiarism are stated below:

• Direct plagiarism occurs when one Copy text word-for-word without attribution.
• Self-plagiarism occurs when reusing one’s previous work without acknowledging that it has been used before.
• Mosaic plagiarism occurs when piecing together information from various sources and presenting it as one’s own.
• Accidental plagiarism occurs when one unintentionally fail to cite sources correctly or misunderstanding citation rules.

Causes of Plagiarism

These are a few typical causes:

• Lack of Understanding: A lot of students are ignorant of the definition of plagiarism and the significance of maintaining academic integrity. They might not understand the difference between straight copying and paraphrase, nor how to properly credit sources.
• Time management problems: Students who procrastinate or manage their time poorly may experience pressure as deadlines draw near. They may replicate other people’s work in a desperate attempt to make their deadlines.
• Academic Pressure: Students may feel pressured to go above and beyond to obtain good marks from parents, professors, or even from themselves. Plagiarism can result from a fear of failing or falling short of these standards.
• Perceived Low Risk: A few pupils think there is little chance of being discovered or that there won’t be any serious repercussions. Plagiarism may appear like a simple way out because of its perceived minimal danger.
• Lack of Confidence: Students who feel their own work is insufficient to receive the required grade may plagiarise because they lack confidence in their writing or research abilities.
• Cultural Differences: The idea of individual authorship and intellectual property may not be as strongly valued in some cultures as it is in others. Plagiarism may not be taken as severely by students from these backgrounds as it is in educational institutions.
• Access to Information: Students are tempted to copy and paste material since it is so simple to obtain information online. Because there is so much content readily available, some students might think that exploiting it without giving due credit is okay.
• Weaknesses in the Educational System: Occasionally, the system fails to place enough emphasis on critical thinking and unique thought. Students may not understand the consequences of plagiarism if they are not taught the importance of producing original work.
• Peer Influence: Students may be more inclined to plagiarise if they witness their peers doing it without being held accountable. Fitting in and feeling pressured by peers can also be factors.
• Laziness: Some students steal content just to avoid having to put in the time and effort necessary to do an assignment independently. Maybe they perceive it as a convenient way out of having to do the work.

Knowing these causes can assist educators in creating tactics to deal with and lessen plagiarism, such as enhancing the teaching of academic integrity, offering greater assistance for time management and writing abilities, and creating an environment that encourages creativity and moral conduct.

A Look at Student Plagiarism Techniques

Low-Tech Lifting

Direct Copying: The classic copy-paste method. Learners might lift entire passages from textbooks, online sources, or even previous assignments (theirs or someone else’s).

Paraphrase Pilfering: Scholars might attempt to paraphrase borrowed content without properly citing the source. This often results in awkward phrasing or a mismatch between the writing style and the student’s usual voice.

Patchwork Plagiarism: Scholars cobble together pieces of information from various sources without proper integration or citation. This creates a disjointed final product lacking a unified voice or argument.

Improper Citation: Learners might cite sources but do so incorrectly, making it difficult to verify the information or identify the original author’s contribution.

Tech-Savvy Shortcuts

Website Mimicry: Scholars might find online essays or articles related to their topic and copy significant portions, making minor changes to appear original.

Paper Pool Piracy: Some scholars might purchase pre-written essays online or share papers amongst themselves, passing them off as their own work.

Remixing and Repurposing: Learners might take a previously submitted assignment (theirs or another student’s) and rework it for a new class, hoping it goes unnoticed.

Beyond Text

Misrepresenting Ideas: Scholars might borrow ideas or arguments from another source without attributing them, even if the phrasing is original.

Data Doctoring: In research projects, learners might fabricate data or manipulate results to fit their desired conclusions.

Multimedia Mishaps: Students might use unattributed images, videos, or graphics in presentations or assignments without proper citation.

Remember that plagiarism can occur accidentally or on purpose. Teachers can be more cautious and steer young minds towards responsible research by being aware of these techniques.

Plagiarism: Then vs. Now

Historically, students had access to books, journals, and other printed materials from which they could copy text without proper attribution.

Plagiarism was often harder to find because it took more time and effort to manually compare texts and there was less access to a larger variety of sources.

In the pre-digital era, teachers and academic institutions relied on their familiarity with students’ writing styles and knowledge levels to identify potential cases of plagiarism.

Teachers would frequently notice differences in the calibre or style of a student’s work, which would prompt them to look into the matter more. In addition, they checked the originality of student responses using conventional techniques like cross-referencing books and other printed materials.

The parallels and discrepancies between plagiarism detection techniques and practices in the pre-technology and contemporary technology eras are compiled in this table.

Aspect	Pre-Technology Era	Modern Technology Era
Existence of Plagiarism	Yes	Yes
Sources	Books, journals, printed materials	Internet, digital content
Detection Methods	Manual effort, familiarity with student work, cross-referencing printed materials	Plagiarism detection software, digital tools
Challenges in Detection	Time-consuming, limited access to wide range of sources	Automated detection, broader access to sources
Motivations for Plagiarism	Pressure to succeed, lack of understanding of citation practices, poor time management, low perceived risk	Pressure to succeed, lack of understanding of citation practices, poor time management, low perceived risk
Identification Methods	Recognising discrepancies in writing style and quality	Using software to compare texts, analysing digital footprints

What Should Teachers Do When Students Plagiarize?

Educating Students

Clear Definitions and Examples: Educate students on what constitutes academic misconduct with clear definitions and examples of plagiarism. Include different types of plagiarism and provide practical exercises for identifying and avoiding them.

Teaching Citation Skills: Offer training sessions on proper citation techniques. Tools like citation guides, workshops, and online resources can be immensely helpful.

Promoting Academic Integrity: Instill a culture of academic integrity by discussing its importance and the consequences of plagiarism regularly.

Assignment Design

Originality-Focused Assignments: Design assignments that require critical thinking and original analysis, making it harder for students to find ready-made answers.

Incremental Submission: Break down large assignments into smaller parts with multiple submission stages (e.g., topic proposal, annotated bibliography, drafts). This approach encourages ongoing engagement and reduces the likelihood of last-minute plagiarism.

Personalised Topics: Assign unique topics to each student to minimise the temptation to copy from peers or online sources.

Use of Technology

Plagiarism Detection Software: Utilise plagiarism detection tools like Bytescare, Turnitin, or Grammarly. These tools can identify unoriginal content and serve as a deterrent against plagiarism.

Digital Footprint Awareness: Educate students about the digital footprint they leave when they plagiarize, including the ease with which online content can be traced back to its source material.

Addressing Plagiarism When It Occurs

Investigating Plagiarism

Gather Evidence: Prior to confronting the student, gather all relevant evidence. These could include papers that the student turned in, reports from plagiarism detection programmes, and online resources.

Recognise the Situation: Examine the circumstances behind the claimed plagiarism. Is this intentional or just an instance of ignorance leading to accidental plagiarism? The severity of the response can be determined by the context.

Communicating with the Student

Private Discussion: Arrange a private meeting with the student to discuss the incident. This approach respects the student’s dignity and allows for an honest conversation.

Calm and Objective Tone: Approach the conversation calmly and objectively. Present the evidence and allow the student to explain their side of the story.

Educational Opportunity: Use the incident as a learning opportunity. Explain why plagiarism is unacceptable and discuss ways to avoid it in the future.

Consequences and Penalties

• Make sure the punishments are appropriate for the seriousness of the offence by making sure they are proportionate. First-time violators might be given a warning and given another chance to complete the project, but repeat offenders might be subject to harsher penalties.
• Apply sanctions uniformly to all pupils in order to preserve the integrity and fairness of the educational process.
• Institutional Rules: Adhere to the plagiarism rules established by the institution. Make sure pupils are aware of these policies and familiarise yourself with them as well.

Long-Term Strategies

Building a Culture of Integrity

• Honor Codes: Implement and uphold an academic honor code that clearly outlines expectations for academic integrity and the consequences of violating the plagiarism policy of an institution.
• Role Modeling: Teachers and faculty members should model ethical behavior in their own work and interactions. This sets a standard for students to follow.
• Community Involvement: Engage the entire academic community, including students, faculty, and administration, in promoting a culture of integrity.

Ongoing Education and Support

• Regular Workshops: Offer regular workshops and training sessions on academic integrity policies, research skills, and proper citation practices.
• Mentorship Programs: Establish mentorship programs where senior students or faculty can guide younger students in developing good academic practices.
• Resource Availability: Provide ample resources, such as writing centers, online tutorials, and access to plagiarism detection tools, to support students in their academic endeavors.

Encouraging Original Work

• Creative Assignments: Encourage creativity and original thought in assignments by allowing students to explore topics of personal interest.
• Collaborative Projects: Promote collaborative projects that emphasise collective knowledge creation and discourage plagiarism.
• Reflection and Feedback: Incorporate reflection exercises and provide constructive feedback to help students understand their learning process and improve their work.

An Innovative Way to Deal With Plagiarism

An innovative way to deal with plagiarism involves shifting the focus from punitive measures to preventive education and the promotion of original thinking.

Emphasising Academic Integrity Through Gamification

Gamification is one creative way to promote academic honesty. Teachers can make the principles of originality and correct citation more approachable and entertaining by including gaming aspects into the teaching process.

• Interactive Learning Modules: Develop interactive modules that teach students about plagiarism and academic integrity through quizzes, puzzles, and scenarios. By completing assignments and proving their mastery, students can earn badges or points from these modules.
• Simulation Games: Create simulation games where students play the role of researchers or journalists. In these simulations, they must gather information, cite sources correctly, and produce original content to progress. Success in the game can translate to a deeper understanding of ethical research practices.
• Leaderboard and Rewards: Set up a leaderboard where students can place themselves in order of originality and correct citation style. Give top performers awards, incentives, or extra credit to encourage them to put academic integrity first.

Personalised Learning Paths

Understanding that each student has unique learning needs and challenges, personalised learning paths can help address the root causes of plagiarism, such as lack of understanding or time management issues.

• Diagnostic Assessments: Use diagnostic assessments at the beginning of the course to identify students’ strengths and weaknesses in research and writing skills. Based on the results, create personalised learning plans that target specific areas for improvement.
• Use adaptive learning technologies: These tools allow you to modify the content and level of difficulty of your course materials according to how well your students are progressing. For learners who are having trouble with citation and research techniques, these technologies can offer more resources and assistance.
• Individualized Support: Offer one-on-one mentoring and tutoring sessions for students who need extra help. Personalised attention can address specific concerns and guide scholars towards better academic practices.

Integrating Technology for Originality

Leveraging technology to promote originality and ethical research practices can be a game-changer in combating plagiarism.

• AI-Powered Writing Assistants: Utilise AI-powered writing assistants that help students with proper citation styles, paraphrasing, and generating original ideas. These tools can provide real-time feedback and suggestions, reducing the likelihood of unintentional plagiarism.
• Originality Checkpoints: Incorporate originality checkpoints throughout the assignment process. For example, require learners to submit outlines, drafts, and final versions of their work through plagiarism detection software. This step-by-step approach ensures that learners maintain originality at every stage.
• Blockchain for Academic Integrity: Explore the use of blockchain technology to create a transparent and immutable record of students’ work. Blockchain can authenticate the originality of assignments and provide a verifiable trail of revisions and citations.

Collaborative Learning and Peer Review

Promoting collaborative learning and peer review can create a supportive environment where scholars learn from each other and hold each other accountable.

• Group Projects: Assign group projects that encourage collaboration and collective responsibility for originality. When scholars work together, they are less likely to resort to academic dishonesty and more likely to engage in meaningful discussions about academic integrity.
• Peer Review Systems: Implement peer review systems where learners evaluate each other’s work. Peer feedback can highlight issues of originality and citation, fostering a community of accountability and support.
• Workshops and Seminars: Organise workshops and seminars on research ethics, citation practices, and the importance of originality. Encourage learners to share their experiences and strategies for maintaining academic integrity.

Encouraging Creative and Critical Thinking

Promoting creative and critical thinking can naturally reduce the temptation to plagiarize by making assignments more engaging and meaningful.

• Open-Ended Questions: Design assignments with open-ended questions that require scholars to think critically and provide unique perspectives. This approach makes it difficult to find ready-made answers and encourages original thought.
• Real-World Applications: Connect assignments to real-world problems and scenarios. When students see the relevance of their work to real-life issues, they are more likely to engage deeply and produce original content.
• Reflective Writing: Include writing assignments that push learners to consider their educational journey, obstacles they encountered, and strategies for overcoming them. By reflecting on the subject matter, one can gain a deeper understanding of it and become less dependent on outside sources.

What’s Next?

In addressing plagiarism, teachers should scan papers and treat “patchwritten” papers as serious academic integrity issues. Utilising class time for reflection pieces and classroom discussions helps reshape students’ conceptions of plagiarism.

Implementing a collaborative model ensures that even advanced students understand the importance of complete sources. Teachers should provide ample time for assignments to prevent last-minute plagiarism.

Anti-plagiarism strategies, such as booking a demo to employ Bytescare plagiarism checkers, assure original work. By adopting these measures, educators can foster a deeper understanding and commitment to academic integrity, encouraging learners to produce entire papers that reflect their own efforts.

FAQs