Photo Copyright Infringement: What You Need to Know

In the digital age, the ease of sharing and distributing photos has increased the incidence of photo copyright infringement. This term refers to the unauthorised use of photographs that are protected by copyright law.

Comprehending what constitutes photo copyright infringement is essential for photographers, content creators, and users alike to ensure legal compliance and respect for intellectual property rights.

What is Photo Copyright?

Photo copyright refers to the legal protection granted to the creators of original photographic works.

This protection is granted to the photographers under Section 2(c) of the Indian Copyright Act 1957.

It is granted as photographs fall under the category of artistic work.

This protection gives the photographer exclusive rights over their images.

This includes the right to reproduce, distribute, display, and create derivative works based on their photographs.

Understanding Copyright Protection for Photographers

Copyright protection is essential for photographers to safeguard their creative work.

The protection starts as soon as the work is created, and copyright registration is recommended, but not mandatory.

According to copyright statute, the expression of an idea is eligible for protection, while the idea itself is not.

Section 51 of the Indian Copyright Act 1957 provides protection for photographers’ expressions against a breach.

Unauthorised use of the photographer’s works is classified as a breach of copyright.

The publication of a photograph without the permission of the author/owner from another published material is also considered an infringement.

However, the use of a photograph without any intention of obtaining illegal profits or for legislative, or academic purposes is permissible without prior consent.

The aforementioned Act of 1957 can overcome the difficulties presented by new technologies and provide complete protection to both traditional and digital images.

It provides photographers with vital protections and a solid legal foundation for copyright protection.

How Long is a Photograph’s Copyright Protection Valid?

The duration of legal protection for photographs varies depending on the country and its specific copyright laws.

It is protected for 60 years from the date of publication under Section 25 of the Copyright Act 1957 in India.

Here a date of publication simply implies when the photograph in question was taken and not when it is published somewhere.

In the European Union and the U.S., it is protected for 70 years, whereas in Berne Convention is protected for a minimum of 50 years from the date it was clicked.

Who Owns the Copyright in Case of Photos?

In general, the copyright owner of a photograph belongs to the person who took the picture, also known as the photographer or creator.

This means that the photographer has the exclusive rights as per the Copyright statute to their photographs, as well as to control how and when their images are used.

However, there are some exceptions and special circumstances that can affect their ownership:

Works made for hire: If an employee takes a photo while on the job, the employer can be deemed the legitimate owner because the snapshot is a “work made for hire.”

In some circumstances, this can also apply to independent contractors, so long as there is a formal contract specifying that the activity is being done for hire.

Copyright transfer: Through a formal agreement, the original owner of the image may elect to give ownership of it to a different person. In these situations, the new owner will be the exclusive owner of the photo and will be in possession of the copyright.

Joint ownership: If a photograph is created by two or more people who intend it to be a single work, they may be considered joint copyright owners. In this case, each owner has equal rights to use, license, or transfer the work, unless there is a written agreement stating otherwise.

What Constitutes Photo Copyright Infringement?

When someone uses a photograph that is protected by copyright without the owner’s consent, it is called photo copyright infringement.

This might be as easy as posting an image on social media, utilising it for a blog entry, or putting it in promotional materials.

Violations can manifest in a number of ways, including:

• Reproducing or copying a copyrighted image without permission, for example, by downloading it from a website and uploading it to your own site.
• Distributing a copyrighted image without permission, such as sharing it on social media platforms, sending it via email, or including it in printed materials.
• Displaying a copyrighted image in a public setting without permission, for instance, using it in a presentation, on a billboard, or as part of a gallery exhibition.
• Creating derivative works based on a copyrighted image without permission, like editing, modifying, or combining it with other images to create a new work.

The Art of Originality in Photography: Understanding the Factors that Make a Photo Unique

Originality in a photograph is determined by the presence of creative elements that result from the photographer’s choices and artistic expression.

These elements make the photograph unique and distinguish it from other works.

Some factors that contribute to the originality of a photograph include:

Composition: The arrangement of subjects, objects, and elements within the frame can reflect the photographer’s creativity and personal style.

The choice of perspective, angles, and overall layout of the image can all contribute to the originality of a photograph.

Lighting: A photographer’s choices on lighting can greatly affect the image’s atmosphere, mood, and aesthetic appeal.

Unique effects can be produced by varying the light’s direction, intensity, and colour as well as by using artificial, natural, or a combination of the two.

Subject matter: An image’s uniqueness can also be enhanced by the subject matter that is chosen. Photographers can opt to document a singular subject or showcase a usual subject in a creative or unconventional manner.

Timing: The precise moment the photograph is taken can be crucial for capturing a unique scene or emotion.

This can be particularly important in genres such as sports photography, wildlife photography, and photo journalism, where timing can make the difference between a standard image and a truly original one.

Post-processing: The photographer’s choices about colour grading, editing, and other post-processing methods can also add to the photograph’s uniqueness. These changes might highlight particular elements, develop a particular visual style, or improve the image’s overall appeal.

In copyright law, a photograph must possess a certain level of originality to be eligible for protection.

While the threshold for originality may vary depending on the jurisdiction, it generally requires that the photograph reflects the photographer’s creative choices and is not a mere mechanical reproduction of a scene or subject.

Illustration

To better depict the idea of uniqueness in a snapshot, let’s look at this:

Imagine Alice and Bob, two photographers, going to a well-liked tourist destination—a mediaeval castle.

They both choose to use the same vantage point to snap pictures of the castle.

Alice’s photo: Alice decides to snap her picture right before dusk in order to get the warm, golden light that illuminates the castle’s exterior. She takes great care to include a stand of trees in the front of her picture, which gives it depth and a feeling of scale.

Alice uses post-processing to bring out the rich tones of the sunset and produce an eye-catching shot by boosting the colours and adjusting the contrast.

Bob’s photograph: Bob, on the other hand, takes his photograph in the middle of the day under flat, even lighting. He decides to center the castle in his frame and doesn’t include any other elements.

His photograph results in straightforward documentation of the castle, with no particular artistic choices or creative elements.

In this case, Alice made some imaginative choices for the lighting, composition, and post-processing, thus her shot would probably be deemed original.

Her choices provide an original and creative depiction of the castle that embodies her sense of fashion and vision.

On the other hand, Bob’s shot might not qualify as unique since it is merely a basic depiction of the topic and doesn’t involve any creative input.

This illustration shows how a photographer’s originality is defined by the artistic choices and expression they make, which distinguish the image from other pieces and add to its distinctiveness.

Navigating Copyright in Photography: Challenges with Originality, Ownership, and Resale

Copyright law is a multifaceted set of rules and provisions designed to safeguard the originality and ownership of creative works.

These ideas are further complicated in the field of photography since it might be difficult to determine the genuine owner and originality of a picture.

Originality is one of the most important components of the aforementioned law in photography.

A photograph’s uniqueness stems from the photographer’s unique perspective and subject selection.

Copyright protection is based on this idea, which also sets one photograph apart from another.

However, being creative isn’t the only way to challenge copyright in photography. Another crucial factor that is subject to disagreement is who owns the photograph.

The legitimate owner of the photograph is the one who hired the photographer, not only for the actual copy but also for the negatives and any related intellectual property.

Furthermore, image copyright regulations also apply to the resale of photographs. According to the Indian Copyright Act of 1957, only the photographer’s owner is permitted to sell or resell the image.

The Bombay High Court was requested to ascertain the tax liability resulting from the sale of photographs in the case of Camera House, Bombay v. State of Maharashtra.

One of the issues that emerged in the case was whether a photographer could sell a customer’s photograph to the customer or anyone else, considering the customer already owns the copyright in the photograph.

The High Court elucidated that under the said Act of 1957, the copyright in a photograph resides in the person who commissioned the photograph, and not in the person who took the photograph.

Consequently, only the owner of the copyright, which in this case is the person who hired the photographer, can sell or resell the photograph.

The court does not need to take into consideration the argument made on behalf of the assessees in this instance in light of the provisions of the Copyright Act because of the decision it made regarding the subject of severability.

Hence, it can be inferred that the person who hires a photographer to take a photograph not only owns the actual copy of the photograph but also the negatives and has the right to sell or resell the photograph, as they possess the intellectual property.

A Guide to Sharing Images Online Without Infringing Copyright

When it comes to sharing images online or using them for various purposes, it’s important to understand the legal implications and limitations to avoid violation of a photographer’s rights.

Here’s a general guideline on what images you can and can’t share:

Images You Can Share:

Public domain images: These are images whose copyright has expired or where the creator has willingly relinquished their rights. Public domain images can be used freely without the need for permission.

Creative Commons licensed images: Creative Commons is a non-profit organisation that provides various licensing options for image creators to share their work with the public while retaining certain rights.

When using a Creative Commons licensed image, you must adhere to the specific license terms, which may include giving appropriate credit, not using the image for commercial purposes, or not creating derivative works.

Stock images with appropriate licenses: Many websites offer stock images that can be used for personal or commercial purposes, either for free or for a fee.

When using stock images, make sure to follow the terms and conditions of the license, which may include limitations on the use or distribution of the image. Examples include Unsplash, Pexels, and Freepik.

When using free stock images on social media, ensure you follow the terms and conditions of the license, which may include limitations on usage or the requirement to provide attribution.

Images you’ve created: If you’ve taken a photograph or created an image yourself, you own the copyright and can share it as you see fit.

However, if the image contains recognisable people, trademarks, or copyrighted elements, you may still need permission from the relevant parties.

Images with explicit permission: If you’ve obtained written permission from the copyright owner to use an image, you can share it according to the terms agreed upon.

Images You Can’t Share:

• Copyrighted images without permission: Sharing or using copyrighted images without permission from the copyright owner is a violation of copyright law and can result in legal consequences.
• Images containing copyrighted elements: Even if you create a new image that incorporates elements from a copyrighted image, it may still be considered a derivative work and subject to copyright infringement claims.
• Images violating privacy or publicity rights: Sharing images of recognisable individuals without their consent, especially if the images are used for commercial purposes or depict them in an unfavorable or sensitive context, may infringe upon their privacy or publicity rights.
• Images containing offensive or illegal content: Sharing images that are offensive, defamatory, or promote illegal activities can result in legal consequences and may violate the terms of service of the platform you’re sharing the images on.

Always exercise caution when sharing images and ensure that you have the appropriate rights or permissions to avoid potential copyright infringement and other legal issues.

When in doubt, take legal advice from an attorney or seek images that are explicitly marked as free for use.

Consequences of Photo Copyright Violation

Violating photo copyright can lead to various legal and financial consequences.

Here are some potential outcomes of photo copyright infringement:

• Cease and desist letter: The copyright holder may send a cease and desist letter, demanding that you immediately stop using the copyrighted image and potentially remove it from your platform or materials.
• Takedown notice: Under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), the copyright holder can issue a takedown notice to the hosting platform, such as a social media site or a web host, requesting the removal of the infringing content. This can result in the removal of the image or even the suspension of your account.
• Fines and damages: If the copyright holder decides to take legal action, you may be liable for financial damages. This can include any earnings you’ve made from using the image without permission as well as actual damages the copyright holder has suffered as a result of the infringement. Statutory damages may be paid under specific circumstances.
• Legal fees: In addition to the financial damages, you may also be responsible for covering the copyright holder’s legal fees and court costs if the case is taken to court and you are found to be infringing on their copyright.
• Injunctions: A court may issue an injunction, which is a legal order that requires you to stop using the copyrighted image and may impose additional restrictions to prevent further infringement.
• Loss of reputation: Violating photo copyright can damage your personal or professional reputation. It may lead to a loss of credibility, trust, or business opportunities.

Always ensure that you have the appropriate rights or permissions to use an image and comply with the terms and conditions associated with the image.

How to Avoid Photo Copyright Infringement?

Respecting photographers’ and artists’ intellectual property rights is crucial to preventing photo copyright infringement.

To reduce the possibility of violation when using photos, abide by following rules:

Utilise your own photos: Using photos that you’ve taken yourself is the most secure method to prevent copyright violations. You will then be the owner of the copyright and in complete control of how the photographs are utilised.

Search for public domain images: Public domain images are not protected by copyright and can be used freely without permission. Look for images that have had their copyright expire or where the creator has relinquished their rights.

Utilise Creative Commons licensed images: Creative Commons provides various licenses that allow creators to share their work while retaining certain rights.

When using a Creative Commons licensed image, ensure that you comply with the specific license terms, such as giving appropriate credit, not using the image for commercial purposes, or not creating derivative works.

Purchase stock images with appropriate licenses: Many websites offer stock images that can be used for personal or commercial purposes, either for free or for a fee. When using stock images, always adhere to the terms and conditions of the license to avoid copyright infringement.

Obtain permission from the copyright owner: If you want to use a copyrighted image, contact the copyright owner to request permission. They may grant you a license to use the image under specific terms and conditions.

Provide proper attribution: When using an image under a license that requires attribution, make sure to give credit to the original photographer or creator according to the terms of the license.

Understand fair use: In some cases, using copyrighted material may be considered fair use, which is a legal doctrine that permits limited use of copyrighted material without obtaining permission.

However, fair use is subjective and depends on specific circumstances, so it’s best to consult with an attorney if you believe your use of an image falls under fair use.

Be cautious with images found online: Just because an image is available online doesn’t mean it’s free to use. Always verify the copyright status and usage permissions for any image you find online before using it.

Remove infringing images promptly: If you receive a notice of copyright infringement or realise that you’ve inadvertently used an image without permission, remove the image immediately and, if necessary, reach out to the actual owner to resolve the copyright issue.

By following these guidelines and respecting the intellectual property rights of photographers and creators, you can minimise the risk of photo copyright infringement while using images for various purposes.

Dealing with the Accusations of Copyright Infringement of Photos

If you’re accused of copyright infringement involving photos, it’s important to take the situation seriously and respond appropriately.

When responding to claims of photo infringement, take into account the following actions:

Review the claim: Carefully examine the notice or communication you’ve received to determine the specific copyright infringement claim being made. Identify the copyrighted work in question, the alleged infringement, and the party making the claim.

Evaluate your use of the image: Assess whether your use of the image constitutes a violation of the photographer’s right.

Take into account elements including whether the image is in the public domain, if you have permission to use it, and whether it qualifies for fair use. If you have any questions concerning the legal implications of your usage, speak with an attorney.

Remove the image: If you believe that you have infringed on the copyright, promptly remove the image from your platform or materials to minimise further damage and show good faith.

Respond to the claim: Once you have a clear understanding of the situation, respond to the accusing party. If you think the claim is legitimate, think about apologising and coming up with a remedy, such paying a licence fee or giving correct credit.

If you believe the claim is baseless, explain your reasoning and provide any supporting evidence, such as a license agreement or proof of public domain status.

Negotiate a settlement: If the accusing party demands payment, you may be able to negotiate a settlement to avoid further legal action. Consult with an attorney to help you navigate this process and reach a fair agreement.

Seek legal assistance: If the dispute cannot be resolved amicably or if you face a lawsuit, consult with an attorney who specialises in copyright law. They can guide you through the legal process and help you build a strong defense.

Prevent future infringement: Gain a thorough awareness of copyright regulations and recommended practices for picture usage to steer clear of future charges of infringement.

Use your own photos, get the owners’ consent, or make use of photographs in the public domain or under a Creative Commons licence.

As always, abide by the usage guidelines for images, and give due credit when credit is due.

By addressing the breach accusations promptly and professionally, you can work to resolve the situation and minimise any potential legal or financial consequences.

How to Protect Your Own Photos from Violation of Copyrights?

Protecting your photos from violations of artistic rights is essential to ensure that no one can use them without your permission or compensation.

Here are some steps you can take to protect your photos:

Put a noticeable watermark on your images: This is a good method of keeping your pictures safe from unauthorised use. In case you are not acquainted with the concept, a watermark refers to an imperceptible symbol or signature superimposed on a photograph to signify its ownership.

Use Copyright Notices: You can also add a copyright notice to your photos, which notifies others that the photo is copyrighted and that it cannot be used without your permission.

Register your images: One of the best ways to ensure that your photos are protected legally is to register them with the Copyright Office. Through this method, you can legally prove that you are the owner of the images and file a lawsuit against anyone who uses them without your consent.

Use Digital Protection Techniques: To protect your pictures digitally, you can also use methods such as encryption, password protection, and digital signature. These methods can prevent others from downloading, copying, or printing your photos without your permission.

Post With Caution: You should be careful where you post your photos online. There are terms and conditions on social networking sites like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter that permit them to utilise the pictures you upload.

Therefore, before uploading your images online, make sure you carefully read the terms and conditions.

The Intersection of Photography and Copyright: Navigating the Future

The future of photography and copyright law is likely to be shaped by several factors, including technological advancements and changes in consumer behavior.

Here are a few potential developments to consider:

• People may now make and share photographs more easily because to social media and digital photography. Because people might not be aware of the regulations governing the use of copyrighted photographs, there might be increased cases of copyright infringement as a result.
• Advances in artificial intelligence and machine learning may make it possible to create new works of art automatically, potentially blurring the lines between original and derivative works. This may lead to new legal challenges around ownership and authorship.
• Blockchain technology has the power to revolutionise copyright enforcement and management. According to some experts, blockchain technology may be used to build smart contracts that automatically enforce copyright agreements and decentralised copyright registries.
• Stock photography and other licenced content may be used more frequently as the market for visual content expands. This would make it easier for photographers and other artists to make money off of their creations, but it might also increase the number of ownership and licencing issues.

As these trends continue to evolve, it will be important for photographers and other creators to stay informed about the latest developments in order to protect their intellectual property and maximise their earning potential.

What’s Next?

Photo copyright infringement poses significant risks to photographers and creators, leading to financial losses and diminished reputation.

Unauthorised use of photos without permission or proper credit undermines the rights of the original creators. To safeguard your work against such breaches, it’s essential to implement robust protection measures.

Book a demo to employ Bytescare digital protection solution to ensure your photos are shielded from copyright infringement.

With Bytescare, you can maintain control over your creative assets and prevent unauthorised usage, ensuring your hard work and creativity are always properly attributed and protected.

FAQs