Can You Patent an Algorithm?

A common question in the tech industry is, “Can you patent an algorithm?” This query gains significance as AI-based products become more prevalent and the algorithm in question often serves as the backbone of innovation.

Patenting an algorithm involves comprehending various aspects of patentability, including how the algorithm in code—a specific type of software code—fits within the context of patent law.

The algorithm idea itself can be a valuable asset for tech companies, especially with the recent advances in machine learning. However, securing a patent requires a comprehensive description that meets legal standards and addresses the aspect of patent eligibility.

Protecting an algorithm through patents not only safeguards intellectual property but also enhances the competitive edge of businesses in a rapidly evolving technological landscape.

This article looks into the intricacies of patenting algorithms, providing insights that are essential for companies looking to protect their innovations.

What is an Algorithm?

An algorithm is a finite set of well-defined instructions or steps designed to perform a specific task or solve a problem. It acts as a blueprint that outlines how to achieve a particular goal through a series of logical procedures.

From basic algorithms that sort numbers to advanced ones powering artificial intelligence (AI), algorithms form the backbone of software applications and computational processes.

Algorithms are typically expressed as mathematical formulas or logical steps, making them abstract in nature. This abstract quality allows them to be universally applicable across various domains, but it also presents challenges in terms of patentability.

Since algorithms are conceptual and not tied to a specific physical embodiment, they often fall into the category of abstract ideas, which are generally not patentable unless applied in a practical context.

In computer science, algorithms are essential for processing data, performing calculations, and automating reasoning tasks. They enable computers to execute complex functions efficiently and effectively. For instance, search engines use algorithms to retrieve relevant information, while encryption algorithms secure data transmission.

With the rapid advancement of AI and machine learning, algorithms have become increasingly sophisticated.

Modern algorithms can learn from vast amounts of data, adapt to new information, and improve their performance over time. These capabilities have led to breakthroughs in fields like natural language processing, image recognition, and autonomous vehicles.

In everyday life, algorithms influence various aspects, from social media feeds to recommendation systems on streaming platforms.

What is a Patent?

A patent is a form of intellectual property that grants the inventor exclusive rights to their invention for a limited period, usually 20 years. During this time, no one else can make, use, or sell the invention without the patent holder’s permission.

Patents are granted for new, non-obvious, and useful inventions or processes. This typically includes machinery, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, and sometimes software, depending on how it is framed.

Types of Patents

There are three main types of patents:

• Utility Patents: The most common type, granted for new and useful inventions or discoveries, which includes machines, processes, and compositions of matter.
• Design Patents: Granted for new, original designs of an object.
• Plant Patents: Granted for the invention or discovery of new plant varieties.

The Patentability of Algorithms

Historically, mathematical algorithms on their own have not qualified for patent protection. However, in jurisdictions like the United States and Europe, patent laws allow algorithms to be patented when they are combined with additional elements under certain conditions.

To obtain a patent for such an algorithm, inventors must demonstrate that their invention—which includes the algorithm and other concrete components—meets the criteria for patentability. This involves showing that the invention is novel, non-obvious, and has a practical application.

Novelty and Non-Obviousness

One of the key requirements for patentability is novelty, meaning the claimed invention must be new and not previously disclosed or publicly known. Additionally, the invention must be non-obvious; it should involve an inventive step that is not immediately apparent to someone skilled in the relevant field.

Practical Application

Another essential requirement is demonstrating a practical application for the invention. The algorithm must have real-world utility and solve a specific technical problem, such as improving the functionality of a computer.

Can You Patent an Algorithm?

The short answer to this question is sometimes, but it depends on how the algorithm is presented and its application in a practical context.

Since an algorithm is essentially a mathematical formula or logical procedure, it is often considered an abstract idea, which generally cannot be patented. However, if an algorithm is tied to a specific application or technological process, it may become patentable.

Patent Law and Algorithms

In the United States, patent law is governed by the Patent Act of 1952, which defines a patent as a grant of a property right to the inventor of a new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter. The law requires that the invention be novel, non-obvious, and useful.

The question of whether an algorithm can be patented is complex and has been the subject of several court cases. In the 1970s, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Gottschalk v. Benson that a mathematical algorithm could not be patented because it was considered a “law of nature” and therefore not eligible for patent protection.

However, in the 1980s, the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) ruled in Diamond v. Diehr that a process that used a mathematical algorithm could be patented if it was tied to a specific machine or apparatus. This decision established the “machine-or-transformation” test, which requires that a patentable process must either be tied to a specific machine or apparatus or transform an article into a different state or thing.

The Alice Test

In 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International that a patent claim that merely recites a generic computer implementation of an abstract idea is not patentable. The Court established a two-step test, known as the Alice test, to determine whether a patent claim is eligible for patent protection.

The first step of the Alice test is to determine whether the patent claim is directed to an abstract idea. If it is, the second step is to determine whether the claim contains an “inventive concept” that transforms the abstract idea into a patentable invention.

Significance of Algorithm Patents

Algorithms drive technological innovation, powering a wide range of industries from software and financial services to healthcare and artificial intelligence (AI).

Patenting algorithms, where allowed, offers inventors and companies critical protections that provide significant legal, financial, and competitive advantages. Below is an in-depth exploration of the significance of patenting of algorithm steps across various dimensions.

Encouraging Innovation and Investment

Patents, including those related to algorithms, incentivise innovation by offering inventors exclusive rights to their inventions for a limited period (usually 20 years). This exclusivity allows the inventor to recover the costs of research and development (R&D), which can be significant in technology-driven fields like software, machine learning, and cryptography.

Providing a Competitive Advantage

Algorithm patents help companies gain competitive market advantages by limiting competitors from using the same or similar technologies. A patented algorithm grants the holder exclusive rights, forcing competitors to either develop alternative solutions, negotiate licenses, or stay out of the market segment altogether.

Monetisation through Licensing and Royalties

Algorithm patents can generate revenue through licensing agreements. Companies that own patented algorithms can license their technology to third parties, allowing them to legally use the algorithm in exchange for royalties or other financial compensation.

Example: Patents related to MP3 compression algorithms were licensed to companies worldwide, generating significant revenues for the inventors before the patents expired.

Legal Protection and Deterrence

Holding a patent for an algorithm provides legal protection against unauthorised use. The patent owner can take legal action against companies or individuals who infringe on their patents, thereby deterring competitors from copying or stealing their innovations.

Example: After securing patents for its PageRank algorithm, Google was able to protect its search engine technology from being copied, maintaining its dominance in search for years.

Some additional significance are as follows:

• AI and Machine Learning: As AI systems increasingly rely on proprietary algorithms, patents help companies protect the models and techniques they develop.
• Quantum Computing: In the future, algorithms designed for quantum computing will likely become the subject of patents, driving further investment and progress.
• Patent Databases as Learning Tools: Researchers and engineers can study patented algorithms to avoid reinventing the wheel or develop improvements upon existing methods.
• Stimulating Competition: Public access to patented algorithms encourages competitors to develop novel, non-infringing solutions, stimulating healthy competition in the market.
• Temporary Monopoly: Algorithm patents provide the patent holder with exclusive rights for a fixed period, after which the technology enters the public domain.
• Standardisation and Open-Source Contributions: Patents can encourage companies to release older algorithms into the public domain once the exclusivity period ends, contributing to industry standards and open-source projects.

Types of Artificial Intelligence Patents

When it comes to Artificial Intelligence (AI) patents, there are various types that have been patented, and the landscape is constantly evolving. From the search results, it appears that AI patents can be broadly categorised into several components, including machine learning, natural language processing, computer vision, and robotics.

• Machine Learning Patents: These patents cover algorithms and techniques that enable machines to learn from data and improve their performance over time. Examples include neural networks, deep learning, and decision trees.
• Natural Language Processing (NLP) Patents: NLP patents focus on the interaction between computers and human language, including speech recognition, text analysis, and language translation.
• Computer Vision Patents: These patents involve algorithms and techniques that enable computers to interpret and understand visual data from images and videos.
• Robotics Patents: Robotics patents cover the integration of AI with physical devices, such as robots, to perform tasks that typically require human intelligence.

Emerging Trends in AI Patents

• Generative AI Patents: These patents involve algorithms that can generate new content, such as text, images, and music, without human intervention.
• Explainable AI (XAI) Patents: XAI patents focus on developing techniques that can explain the decisions made by AI systems, increasing transparency and trust in AI.

Case Study: Patent Examples

Examining successful patent filings from comparable companies can provide valuable insights for your own patent strategy. Here are a few notable examples of recent software patents in the machine learning space.

Google’s “Dropout” Patent

Google holds a patent for the dropout technique in machine learning, which is a widely used method to improve model performance by disregarding certain inputs during training. This broad patent serves to protect the underlying principle of dropout, effectively preventing competitors from utilising this technology without permission.

Coinbase’s Instant Exchange System

Coinbase, a leading cryptocurrency platform, patented its instant exchange system for bitcoin transactions. This innovative algorithm enables immediate exchanges between merchants and customers without incurring miner fees, streamlining the transaction process.

Airbnb’s Booking Prediction Algorithm

Airbnb secured a patent for its machine learning algorithm designed to predict the likelihood of property bookings. This predictive model continuously learns and enhances its accuracy based on new data inputs, helping to optimize booking strategies for both short-term and long-term rentals.

Patent Rights Vs. Copyright Rights for Algorithms

When it comes to protecting algorithms, understanding the differences between patent rights and copyright rights is crucial. Both forms of intellectual property offer distinct protections and serve different purposes.

Patent Rights

• Scope: Patents protect inventions, including algorithms, as long as they meet criteria such as novelty, non-obviousness, and usefulness. This means the algorithm must offer a new solution or method that is not evident to someone skilled in the field.
• Duration: Patent protection typically lasts for 20 years from the filing date, after which the invention enters the public domain.
• Enforcement: Patent holders can prevent others from making, using, or selling the patented invention without permission, providing a strong competitive edge.

Copyright Rights

• Scope: Copyright protects the expression of ideas, including the source code or documentation of an algorithm, rather than the algorithm itself. This means that while the written code is protected, the underlying method or concept may not be.
• Duration: Copyright protection lasts for the life of the author plus 70 years, but it can vary depending on the jurisdiction.
• Enforcement: Copyright holders can control the reproduction, distribution, and adaptation of their work, but cannot prevent others from using the same underlying algorithm if expressed differently.

The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Algorithm Development

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has revolutionised algorithm development by introducing data-driven approaches that augment traditional methods. Traditionally, algorithms were manually crafted sets of instructions designed to perform specific tasks.

With the advent of AI, particularly machine learning and deep learning, algorithms can now be developed that learn and adapt from data without explicit programming.

One significant role of AI is in automating the creation of algorithms. Machine learning models can analyse vast datasets to identify patterns and generate algorithms that optimise performance for specific tasks. For example, neural architecture search uses AI to design neural networks tailored to particular problems, outperforming manually designed counterparts.

AI also enhances algorithm efficiency and effectiveness. Techniques like reinforcement learning enable algorithms to improve through trial and error, adapting to changing environments. Additionally, AI aids in optimising existing algorithms by tuning parameters and selecting the best configurations, thereby improving accuracy and speed.

Moreover, AI expands the scope of algorithm development into complex domains like natural language processing, computer vision, and robotics. In these areas, AI-driven algorithms can handle unstructured data, recognise patterns, and make decisions in ways traditional algorithms cannot.

For instance, convolutional neural networks have become essential in image recognition tasks due to their ability to automatically learn hierarchical features from raw data.

What’s Next?

Patenting an algorithm is a complex yet attainable goal that hinges on several critical factors. While mathematical methods and abstract ideas are generally not patentable, algorithms that demonstrate a specific technical solution can be protected under intellectual property rights.

Tech companies and human inventors must carefully craft their patent applications to highlight the unique aspects and level of innovation in their machine learning techniques.

For software developers and the broader community for developers, understanding the scope of protection is essential to avoid potential infringements and to foster continuous learning in the field.

Given the nuanced differences between patent and copyright law, especially concerning AI-related patents, seeking professional legal advice is highly recommended. This ensures that your innovation not only receives the protection it deserves but also complies with all legal requirements.

Protecting your algorithm enhances your competitive edge and contributes to the advancement of technology as a whole.

Protect your patented algorithm with Bytescare’s comprehensive security measures, ensuring your ideas remain exclusively yours.

Ready to see how Bytescare can secure your patents and safeguard your innovations? Book a demo today and experience our solutions firsthand!

FAQs