Can You Copyright a Recipe?

When you think about copyright, images of books, movies, or songs probably come to mind. But what about recipes? If you’ve ever worked hard to perfect a dish, it’s natural to wonder whether your creation can be protected from being copied by others.

After all, recipes represent creativity and skill, just like any other art form. Yet, when it comes to copyright, the legal aspect around recipes is a bit more complicated than it seems.

In this comprehensive guide, “Can You Copyright a Recipe?” we’ll explore whether you can copyright a recipe, what aspects of it may or may not be protected, and how you can safeguard your culinary creations from being freely used by others.

What is Copyright?

Copyright is a legal protection granted to the creators of original works, giving them exclusive rights to control how their creations are used. This protection applies to various forms of creative expression, including literature, music, art, films, software, and more.

With copyright, the creator has the right to determine how their work is distributed, reproduced, performed, or displayed, and others must obtain permission to use it.

For a work to qualify for copyright protection, it must meet two key criteria: originality and fixation in a tangible form. This means that ideas, by themselves, cannot be copyrighted; they need to be expressed in a specific medium.

For example, the concept of a story is not protected by copyright, but once written down in the form of a book, it qualifies for protection. Similarly, a song idea is not protected until it’s composed and recorded.

This distinction helps safeguard the creator’s rights over their tangible, creative expressions. But when it comes to culinary arts, things get complicated. A list of ingredients or basic cooking instructions often falls into the realm of factual information, which isn’t protected by copyright.

So, while a painting or book can be copyrighted, can the same be said for a recipe?

Can You Copyright a Recipe?

The short answer is: It depends.

Under U.S. copyright law, recipes in their basic form—such as ingredient lists and instructions—are not eligible for copyright protection. According to the U.S. Copyright Office, functional works, like a recipe, which serve as a method or process, cannot be copyrighted.

A simple listing of ingredients or steps, like “2 cups of flour” or “bake at 350°F for 20 minutes,” lacks the creativity or originality required for copyright. Copyright law is designed to protect original works of authorship, not functional methods.

What Does This Mean?

• Ingredient Lists: A basic list of ingredients, such as “2 cups of flour, 1 tsp of salt,” is considered factual and not protected by copyright.
• Methods or Processes: The steps or instructions to create a dish (e.g., “bake at 350°F for 20 minutes”) are not copyrightable, as copyright law doesn’t protect processes or methods of operation.

However, recipes that include creative elements—such as vivid descriptions, storytelling, or personal commentary—can be copyrighted. For instance, a recipe that describes steps with unique expressions or narratives could qualify for protection. While the functional part remains free to use, the creative expression is protected.

What Parts of a Recipe Are Copyrightable?

While the basic elements of a recipe (ingredients and methods) are not copyrightable, the expressive elements around the recipe can be. Here’s what that entails:

Copyrightable Aspects of a Recipe:

Descriptions and Storytelling: If a recipe is presented with a unique, expressive narrative or background story, that specific expression can be copyrighted. For instance, if you add a story about the origin of the dish, how you discovered it, or personal anecdotes, this content can be protected.

You might write something like:

“This apple pie recipe has been in our family for over a century. My great-grandmother used to bake it every Sunday after church, filling the house with the warm aroma of cinnamon and apples. She always insisted on using Granny Smith apples, picked fresh from her orchard, for the perfect balance of tart and sweet. Every bite brings back memories of family gatherings in her cozy kitchen, the sound of laughter echoing as we waited for the pie to cool just enough to dig in.”

In this case, the narrative—the story of your great-grandmother and the family tradition—becomes a creative element that is protected by copyright. While others can use the recipe itself, they cannot copy your unique storytelling without permission.

Creative Presentation: If the recipe is published in a cookbook or blog with original, artistic photos, illustrations, or unique design elements, those creative parts can be copyrighted.

Commentary: Any original commentary, reviews, or opinions about the recipe that are included in the presentation can be copyrighted.

Example:

An Italian grandmother’s pasta recipe may not be copyrightable in terms of ingredients or steps, but a blog post that includes a heartfelt story about her life in Tuscany and how she passed the recipe down to her grandchildren could be protected. The expressive elements, not the functional cooking instructions, are what fall under copyright.

For instance, the blog might read:

“Growing up in a sun-drenched village in Tuscany, my grandmother would spend her afternoons crafting pasta from scratch. The kitchen was her sanctuary, where flour danced in the air, and the aroma of simmering tomatoes filled the home. Every Sunday, she would gather her grandchildren, teaching us not just how to make pasta, but also the importance of family, love, and tradition. As she rolled the dough with care, she shared stories of her childhood, of feasts with neighbors, and of laughter echoing through the hills. This recipe is not just about ingredients; it is a legacy of love and togetherness that I cherish and pass down to my own children.”

In this example, the expressive elements—the memories, the rich descriptions, and the emotional connections—are what fall under copyright protection, while the basic recipe itself remains in the public domain.

Limitations of Recipe Copyrights

While some parts of a recipe may be copyrighted, there are notable limitations on what can be protected. Here’s a summary of these limitations:

• Functional Elements Are Not Protectable: The list of ingredients, instructions, and basic cooking methods are considered functional aspects of a recipe. Since they serve a practical purpose, they do not meet the originality standard required by copyright law.
• Ideas Are Not Copyrightable: The concept behind a recipe, such as “a chocolate chip cookie with sea salt,” cannot be copyrighted. Only the specific, creative expression of that idea, such as how the recipe is described or presented, can be protected.
• Common Dishes: Recipes for standard dishes like apple pie or spaghetti bolognese are typically not eligible for copyright protection. They are too common and lack the originality required for copyright.

Because of these limitations, recipe creators must explore other intellectual property options, such as trademarks or patents, to protect their work. 

Copyright vs. Other Forms of Protection

While copyright offers limited protection for recipes, there are other forms of intellectual property that may offer stronger protections for culinary creations.

Trademark

A trademark protects words, phrases, symbols, or designs that distinguish the source of goods or services. In the context of recipes, you could trademark a brand name for a dish or product. For example, a restaurant could trademark a signature dish’s name or logo to prevent competitors from using the same branding.

Example of Trademarked Foods:

• Big Mac: McDonald’s famous burger name is trademarked.
• Dole Whip: A frozen treat with a trademarked name, even though the recipe itself isn’t protected.

Patent

A patent protects new inventions, including novel food preparation processes or formulas. However, getting a patent for a recipe is quite difficult and rare. Patents are more commonly applied to industrial food processes rather than individual recipes.

Example of Patented Food Processes:

• Coca-Cola’s original bottling process.
• Nestlé’s instant coffee manufacturing process.

Trade Secret

A trade secret refers to confidential business information that provides a competitive edge. The recipe for Coca-Cola is one of the most famous examples of a trade secret. Trade secret protection requires that the recipe be kept confidential and shared only with trusted individuals under non-disclosure agreements.

Cookbooks Can Be Protected as Copyrightable Compilations

A cookbook can be protected under copyright law as a compilation if the selection, arrangement, and coordination of the recipes are creative. This means that while the individual recipes themselves are not eligible for copyright protection, the way they are organised within the cookbook can be.

The copyright for a compilation covers the creative aspects of how the recipes are grouped or presented, not the actual content of each recipe. This concept was clarified in the Supreme Court case Feist Publications, Inc. v. Rural Telephone Service Co., Inc., which explained that factual compilations can be copyrighted, but protection is limited to the “particular selection or arrangement” of the information, not the facts themselves.

In practical terms, someone could copy an individual recipe from a copyrighted cookbook without violating copyright law, as the protection only applies to the creative organisation of the collection.

However, copying the entire cookbook’s layout or recipe arrangement could infringe on the copyright, since that is the creative element covered by the law. Thus, while the online recipes are free to use, the unique presentation and compilation are not.

How to Protect a Recipe Legally?

Given the limitations of copyright protection, you may wonder how you can protect a recipe. Here are some alternative strategies:

Trademark Law: If you’ve created a signature dish or food product, you can trademark its name, logo, or any branding elements. This protects your dish’s identity and prevents others from using the same name or branding.

Trade Secret Law: Keep your recipe confidential and share it only with trusted employees under non-disclosure agreements (NDAs). This ensures your recipe remains a secret and legally protected.

Engaging Story: Adding personal stories or unique descriptions to your recipe can make it more appealing and allow you to copyright the creative original expression.

Sell or License Recipes: Licensing allows you to let others use your recipe under set terms, similar to franchising. It ensures your control over how the recipe is used commercially.

Non-Compete Agreements: If you’re sharing a proprietary recipe with employees, having them sign non-compete agreements prevents them from using it to start a competing business, providing further protection.

What’s Next?

While the ingredient list of a recipe cannot be copyrighted, non-ingredient list elements like the literary expression surrounding a recipe in a recipe book or recipe cards may qualify for copyright protection. This is a common area of misconception among food creators and recipe bloggers.

Recipes as food creations aren’t eligible for full copyright protection, but the creative aspects of presenting them can be protected.

Business owners and food creators should be aware of copyright infringement risks and explore other ways to secure their work.

To protect your recipes and prevent unauthorised use, Bytescare offers advanced copyright protection solutions. Book a demo to explore how our technology safeguards your culinary creations.

FAQs