What is Copyright Infringement

If you are a digital creator, wondering ‘what is copyright infringement?’, we have provided you the answer in detail in this blog.

In the digital age, it’s never been easier to access information, but with that ease comes the potential for misuse. Copyright infringement is a prevalent issue that affects content creators, businesses, and consumers alike.

But what exactly is infringement? In simple terms, it’s the unauthorised use of copyrighted material without permission from the copyright owner.

What is Copyright Violation?

Copyright violation, also known as  infringement, occurs when someone uses, distributes, or reproduces copyrighted material without the proper permission or authorisation from the  holder.

Infringement can take many forms, including:

1. Unauthorised copying or distribution: Sharing copyrighted material, such as books, movies, music, or software, without permission.
2. Creating derivative works: Modifying or adapting copyrighted material to create a new work without the holder’s consent.
3. Public performance or display: Playing a copyrighted song or movie in a public setting without obtaining the necessary permissions or licenses.
4. Plagiarism: Using someone else’s copyrighted work and presenting it as your own without proper attribution.

What Constitutes Copyright Infringement?

Copyright infringement occurs when someone uses, reproduces, distributes, or modifies a copyrighted work without the permission or authorisation of the holder.

1. Valid copyright: The work in question must be protected. This generally means it must be an original work of authorship, fixed in a tangible medium of expression, and within the scope of protection.
2. Copying or use of the work: The alleged infringer must have engaged in copying or using the copyrighted work in some way. This could involve making physical copies, distributing files online, publicly performing the work, or incorporating it into a new work.
3. Substantial similarity: The alleged infringing work must be substantially similar to the original copyrighted work. This means that an average observer would recognise the similarities between the two works and believe that one was derived from the other.
4. Unauthorised use: The use of the copyrighted work must be unauthorised by holder. If permission or a license was granted, then the use is not considered infringement.

Copyright Violation Cases in India

In India, violations are governed by the Copyright Act of 1957, which grants protection to various types of original works, such as literary, artistic, musical, and dramatic works, as well as sound recordings and cinematographic films.

The Act has been amended several times to keep up with technological advancements and international treaties. Here are some notable violation cases in India:

1. Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. Chintamani Rao (2002): In this case, the plaintiff, Super Cassettes Industries Ltd., held the copyright for various music albums, while the defendant was accused of manufacturing and selling infringing copies of the copyrighted works. The Bombay High Court granted an injunction in favor of the plaintiff, restraining the defendant from duplicating, selling, or distributing the infringing copies.
2. The Chancellor, Masters & Scholars of the University of Oxford v. Rameshwari Photocopy Service (2016): This case, often referred to as the “Delhi University photocopy case,” involved a photocopy shop that made and sold course packs containing photocopied excerpts from copyrighted textbooks to Delhi University students. The plaintiffs, a group of international publishers, sued the shop for infringement. However, the Delhi High Court ruled in favor of the defendants, stating that the reproduction of copyrighted works for educational purposes fell within the “fair dealing” exception under Indian law.

Types of Works Protected by Copyright

Copyright protects a wide range of creative works, such as:

1. Literary works: This category encompasses books, articles, poems, and other written materials. Copyright protection for literary works covers the expression of ideas in writing, not the ideas themselves.

2. Music and sound recordings: Original musical compositions and lyrics, as well as sound recordings, are protected by copyright. This includes songs, instrumentals, and even sound effects.

3. Dramatic works: Plays, screenplays, and other dramatic works are protected. The protection extends to both the written scripts and any accompanying music or choreography.

4. Motion pictures and other audiovisual works: Movies, television shows, and other forms of audiovisual media are protected under law. This includes the visual and audio elements, as well as the script and any accompanying music.

5. Architectural works: Building designs, architectural plans, and completed structures can be protected under law. Protection covers the overall design and any unique, artistic elements of a building.

6. Visual art: Paintings, sculptures, photographs, and other forms of visual art are protected by copyright. This includes both traditional art forms and digital creations.

7. Software and code: Computer programs and the source code behind them are protected by law. This includes both the underlying code and any unique visual or audio elements that form part of the software.

How Does Copyright Infringement Occur?

Copyright infringement can take various forms, often categorised into three main types: direct, contributory, and vicarious. Understanding these types of infringement can help you identify potential risks and avoid exclusive rights and trouble.

Direct Infringement

Direct infringement occurs when an individual or entity directly engages in unauthorised copying or use of copyrighted material. This can include actions like:

• Reproducing a copyrighted work without permission, such as making unauthorised copies of a book, CD, or movie.
• Distributing copyrighted material without permission, either online (e.g., file sharing) or offline (e.g., selling unauthorised copies).
• Publicly performing or displaying a copyrighted work without permission, such as playing a movie in a public venue or using a copyrighted image on a website.
• Creating derivative works based on copyrighted material without permission, like creating a sequel to a novel or adapting a book into a screenplay.

Contributory Infringement

Contributory infringement happens when someone knowingly provides assistance or resources that enable another party to infringe.

In this case, the contributor doesn’t directly engage in the unauthorised use of copyrighted material but is still held responsible for facilitating the infringement. Examples of contributory infringement include:

• Providing software, tools, or platforms that enable users to share copyrighted material illegally, such as peer-to-peer file-sharing services.
• Selling or distributing devices designed to circumvent protection measures, like DVD-copying software or modded gaming consoles.
• Encouraging or instructing others to engage in infringement, such as writing a guide on how to download copyrighted movies illegally.

Vicarious Infringement

Vicarious infringement occurs when someone has the power to control or benefit from the infringement committed by another party, even if they didn’t directly participate in the infringement.

The vicarious infringer has the ability to control or supervise the infringing activities.

• The vicarious infringer derives a direct financial benefit from the infringement, such as increased revenue or reduced expenses.
• The vicarious infringer fails to take reasonable steps to prevent the infringement from occurring.

Common Examples of Copyright Infringement

Music and Sound Recordings

Illegal Downloading and File Sharing

One of the most prevalent examples of  infringement in music is the unauthorized downloading and file sharing of copyrighted songs and sound recordings.

This can occur through peer-to-peer networks, torrent sites, or direct downloads from unauthorized sources.

Such actions deprive artists and record labels of revenue and can have severe legal consequences for those involved in the infringement.

Unauthorised Sampling and Remixing

Another example of music infringement is the unauthorized sampling of copyrighted music or the creation of remixes without the original artist’s permission.

While some artists may permit or even encourage fan-made remixes, using copyrighted material without permission can lead to legal action.

Movies and Television Shows

Streaming and Downloading Pirated Content

The unauthorized streaming or downloading of copyrighted movies and television shows is a widespread form of copyright infringement.

This can occur through illegal streaming sites, torrenting, or other methods of acquiring pirated content.

Accessing and distributing copyrighted video content without permission can result in legal, criminal penalties and financial damages.

Public Performances Without Permission

Publicly displaying copyrighted movies or television shows without obtaining the proper licenses is another form of copyright infringement.

This can include showing films at public events, using copyrighted video material in presentations, or even hosting a public viewing at a private residence without obtaining the necessary permissions.

Literary Works

Plagiarism and Unauthorised Distribution

Plagiarism, or copying someone else’s written work without proper attribution, is a common form of copyright infringement involving literary works.

This can include anything from copying entire passages or articles to paraphrasing without adequate credit.

Unauthorised distribution of copyrighted literary works, such as sharing digital copies of books or articles without permission, is also considered copyright infringement.

Creating Derivative Works Without Permission

Creating derivative works based on copyrighted literary material, such as adapting a novel into a screenplay or writing fanfiction without the original author’s permission, is another form of copyright infringement.

While some authors may be more lenient about derivative works, it is always best to seek permission from the copyright holder before creating any adaptations or new works based on their original content.

Consequences of Copyright Infringement

Legal Penalties

When someone is found guilty of copyright infringement, they can face various legal penalties, depending on the nature and extent of the infringement. Legal penalties for copyright infringement can include:

1. Cease and desist orders: A court may issue a cease and desist order, requiring the infringing party to stop the unauthorised use of copyrighted material immediately.
2. Injunctions: A court may grant an injunction to prevent the infringing party from continuing to use or distribute the copyrighted material.
3. Criminal charges: In some cases, copyright infringement can result in criminal charges, leading to fines and even imprisonment. This typically occurs in instances of large-scale piracy or counterfeiting operations.
4. Seizure and destruction of infringing materials: Courts can order the seizure and destruction of any materials that infringe on copyrights, such as pirated DVDs, unauthorised merchandise, or counterfeit products.

Financial Compensation

In addition to legal penalties, copyright holders can seek financial compensation from the infringing party for the unauthorised use of their work.

Financial compensation for copyright infringement can take several forms:

1. Actual damages: Copyright holders can claim actual damages, which represent the financial losses they have suffered as a result of the infringement. This can include lost sales, reduced royalties, or decreased licensing fees.
2. Statutory damages: In some cases, copyright ownership can seek statutory damages, which are predetermined amounts set by copyright law for each instance of infringement. Statutory damages can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars per infringement of copyright, depending on the circumstances and the severity of the violation.
3. Profits attributable to infringement: Copyright holders can also seek compensation for any profits the infringing party made as a result of the unauthorized use of their work. This may include revenue generated from sales, advertising, or licensing fees related to the infringing material.
4. Legal fees and court costs: In many cases, copyright holders can also recover their legal fees and court costs associated with pursuing a copyright infringement lawsuit.

Preventing and Responding to Copyright Infringement

Understanding Fair Use

Fair use is a legal doctrine that allows limited use of copyrighted material without obtaining permission from the rights holders.

It is intended to promote creativity, scholarship, and commentary by allowing certain uses of copyrighted works that would not otherwise be permitted.

To determine if a particular use of copyrighted material is considered fair use, courts typically consider the following factors:

1. The purpose and character of the use, such as whether it is for commercial or non-profit educational purposes.
2. The nature of the copyrighted work, with more protection given to creative works than factual ones.
3. The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole.

Understanding fair use and its limits can help you avoid infringing on someone else’s copyright, as well as defend your own rights when facing infringement claims.

Responding to Infringement Claims

If you are accused of copyright infringement, it is essential to respond promptly and appropriately to the claim. Steps to consider when responding to infringement claims include:

1. Review the claim carefully to determine its validity and ensure that the copyrighted work in question is legitimately owned by the claimant.
2. Evaluate your use of the copyrighted material to see if it falls under fair use or if you have obtained the necessary permissions.
3. If you believe the claim is unfounded, consider consulting with a legal professional specialising in intellectual property law to help you build a defence or negotiate a resolution.
4. If you have inadvertently infringed on someone else’s copyright, take immediate steps to remedy the situation. This can include removing the infringing material, obtaining proper permissions, or negotiating a settlement with the rights holder.

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding the complexities of copyright infringement is essential in today’s digital age, where sharing and repurposing content is easier than ever.

By respecting the intellectual property rights of others, recognising the scope of fair use, and obtaining permission when necessary, individuals and businesses can avoid potential legal and financial consequences.

FAQs